- gifting umrah vs charity
Gifting Umrah vs. Charity: Which Gift Reaches Your Loved One?
Published on Nov 15, 2026

Gifting Umrah vs. Charity: Which Gift Reaches Your Loved One?

Umrah and charity are not rivals. Scholars treat both as deeds whose reward can reach another person, and they work differently. A gifted or proxy Umrah is a ritual performed in full for one named person. Charity is a financial act whose benefit spreads to others, and sadaqah jariyah keeps flowing. If someone you love cannot travel or has passed away, a proxy Umrah gives them a pilgrimage of their own, and many families pair it with charity in the same person’s name. We perform Umrah on behalf of others, so we will explain the rulings first and the options after.
TL;DR
- Umrah can be gifted in two ways: you give the reward of your own Umrah to someone, or you send a proxy to perform Umrah in their name.
- A proxy Umrah for a living person is valid when they have a lasting inability to travel, such as old age or chronic illness, and they give permission. For someone who has died, it is permitted and the reward reaches them.
- Charity (sadaqah) is also rewarded for the living and the deceased. Sadaqah jariyah, such as a well, keeps rewarding as long as people benefit from it.
- Choosing between them is not required. Many families do both: a proxy Umrah for the pilgrimage and charity for lasting benefit.
Table of Contents
- Two ways to gift Umrah
- How charity and sadaqah jariyah work
- Gifting Umrah and charity side by side
- Gifting Umrah to someone who is alive
- Gifting Umrah or charity for someone who has died
- Conditions for a valid proxy Umrah
- Gifting Umrah and giving charity together
- Our packages for a proxy Umrah
- Our view: a gift that finishes what they could not
- FAQ
- Sources
Two ways to gift Umrah
People use “gifting Umrah” for two different things, and the rulings differ.
Gifting the reward. You perform your own Umrah and intend that its reward go to someone else. Islamweb.net states that gifting the reward of your own Umrah to a living person is valid and the reward reaches him. The scholarly term is isal al-thawab, sending reward. Turkey’s Diyanet Affairs Presidency notes that the Hanafi school allows this. You can read more on the difference in our guide to gifting the reward or sending a proxy.
Sending a proxy. Someone else performs the whole Umrah in the name of the person it is for. This is called Umrah badal, meaning substitute. It is not a symbolic gesture. The proxy enters ihram (the sacred state for pilgrimage) with the intention for that person, then completes tawaf, sa’i and the trim or shave for them.

The first is a gift of reward from your own worship. The second is a pilgrimage completed for another person. If your loved one is too ill or too old to travel, or has died, the second is the one that answers the need.
How charity and sadaqah jariyah work
Sadaqah is voluntary giving. Ordinary sadaqah benefits the recipient once, like a meal. Muslim Hands explains that sadaqah jariyah benefits people repeatedly and keeps rewarding the giver even after death, with a water well as the usual example.
The legal reason is that sadaqah jariyah falls under waqf, an endowment. Zakat.org describes how the original property is held in place while its fruits keep serving the people it was set aside for, unlike ordinary sadaqah, which becomes the recipient’s property.
Charity on behalf of the deceased is widely accepted. Human Appeal reports that the majority of scholars across the four Sunni schools hold that charity given for a deceased person is permissible and its reward is transferred to them.
The Arab News fatwa column draws a useful line. Financial acts like sadaqah may be offered on behalf of others, and so may Hajj and Umrah, which the Prophet ﷺ allowed explicitly. Scholars disagree about doing prayer or fasting by proxy, and tawaf on its own for another person is not prescribed.
Gifting Umrah and charity side by side
| Gifted reward of your own Umrah | Proxy Umrah (badal) | Ordinary sadaqah | Sadaqah jariyah | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | You intend your reward for someone | Another person performs the full Umrah in the name of the beneficiary | One-time giving | Ongoing giving, such as a well |
| For the living | Valid | Valid if they have a lasting inability and give permission | Valid | Valid |
| For the deceased | Valid | Valid, and it frees them of the obligation | Valid | Valid |
| Who acts | You, after traveling yourself | A trusted proxy who has done his own Umrah | You | You |
| Reward pattern | Your reward is shared | A completed pilgrimage in their name | Single benefit to the recipient | Continues while people benefit |
The table shows why the question “which is better” is usually the wrong one. Each does something the others do not.
Gifting Umrah to someone who is alive
This is where most questions come from: “Can I gift Umrah to a friend?” The answer depends on what you want to give.
If you want to give them the reward of your own Umrah, it is valid, as above. You do not need their permission to wish them good, and you do not need to be related.
If you want a proxy to perform Umrah in their name, the conditions are stricter. Islamweb.net says a proxy Umrah avails a living person only if he is chronically incapable of performing it himself. He must also give permission, and the deputy must have performed his own Umrah first. Jordan’s Iftaa’ Department rules the same: illness not expected to be cured, or old age, allows appointing a proxy, and the proxy must have the living person’s consent.
The Arab News column adds the other side. Proxy Umrah is not for a person who is physically and financially able but busy or unenthusiastic.
So a friend who is healthy and could travel but has not is not a case for a proxy. If someone only needs help getting there, the better gift may be the journey itself, and for an elderly relative who can still travel with support, arrangements such as airport pickup for elderly travelers make the trip easier on arrival.
If your parent or grandparent truly cannot travel, our guide on Badal Umrah for an elderly parent walks through the rulings. For a family facing a serious diagnosis, see arranging Umrah for a terminally ill person.

Gifting Umrah or charity for someone who has died
This is the most common reason families come to us, and the guidance is clear and comforting.
Islamweb.net states that Umrah on behalf of a deceased person frees him of the obligation and the reward reaches him. Shaykh Ibn Baz ruled that Umrah and charity on behalf of the deceased are both permissible and rewarded, and that Umrah, charity and supplication all benefit the deceased.
The Permanent Committee for Scholarly Research and Ifta, in a fatwa on parents, holds that both giving charity for deceased parents and performing Hajj or Umrah for them are recommended. That ruling does not ask you to pick one.
The Hanafi school has a long tradition on this point. An IslamQA answer says it is permissible to perform Umrah with the intention of giving the reward to a deceased mother, and it points to the well of Umm Saad as a classic example of sadaqah jariyah, so the two are mentioned together.
Does the proxy have to be a relative?
No. Islamweb.net states that any person who has already performed Hajj and Umrah for himself can do it on behalf of any other person. That is why a family in the United States can arrange Umrah for a parent who passed away in another country, with a trusted proxy in Makkah.
Conditions for a valid proxy Umrah
These points come up most often in the scholarly answers. Schools differ in details, so a family that follows a particular madhhab should check the specifics. Our rulings by madhhab guide sets them side by side.
- The proxy is a Muslim adult of sound mind who has performed his own Umrah. IslamQA.info cites the hadith of Shubrumah for this condition. Amalkit’s fiqh summary notes the Hanafi school is more lenient, while the Shafi’i and Hanbali schools require it.
- The beneficiary has died or has a lasting inability. Old age, chronic illness or a disability with no hope of recovery qualify, per the Iftaa’ Department ruling above.
- A living beneficiary gives permission. The proxy must have the person’s consent.
- The intention is for one person. The intention is made at ihram. It is not essential to say the name aloud, because the intention in the heart suffices, though saying it in the talbiyah is preferable.
- One Umrah is for one person. If you want Umrah for several people, each needs a separate Umrah. Our guide on multiple proxy Umrahs explains how this works.
- The proxy performs it himself. Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem’s site says a trustworthy deputy may be paid to perform it, but passing the task to someone else without approval is not allowed.
The proxy’s procedure is the same as for his own Umrah apart from the intention. Islamweb.net describes how, after his own Umrah, he goes to At-Tan’im outside the sacred precincts to enter ihram for the second one.
The sixth condition matters when you pay. A family is trusting a stranger with a sacred act, so it is reasonable to want to know who the proxy is, what he will do, and how you will see that it was done. Our guide on Saudi fatwas, eligibility and proof before you pay covers that.
Gifting Umrah and giving charity together
Putting the two side by side, here is a practical way to decide.
- You want a pilgrimage completed for someone who cannot make it. Choose a proxy Umrah. Charity does not replace the pilgrimage itself, and the scholars treat Umrah as a distinct act.
- You want a lasting benefit in someone’s name. Sadaqah jariyah suits this. A well, a school or a similar endowment keeps benefiting people, and the deceased person’s reward continues with it.
- You want to honor a parent in both ways. The Permanent Committee fatwa recommends both for deceased parents, so you can do both.
- You are giving for a friend who is healthy. Gift the reward of your own Umrah, or give charity in their name. A proxy is for people who cannot travel.
Scholars also say that those near you who are in urgent need deserve your attention, and a family can honor that by giving charity alongside any Umrah. The Al-Mawrid scholar Dr Shehzad Saleem explains the matter is one of circumstance and liberty: you decide according to what you can do, and neither one cancels the other.
The practical point is that Umrah is a one-off act on a given date, while charity can be given at any time, in any amount, and repeated. Doing a proxy Umrah this year and a monthly charity in the same name is a common and reasonable plan.
Our packages for a proxy Umrah
When you are ready to arrange a proxy Umrah, we offer four Umrah packages with a single fixed fee and no recurring charges. Each comes with proof of completion in the form of photos, videos and a certificate:
- Du’a Package: $150
- Noor Package: $250
- Barakah Package: $400
- Jariyah Premium Package: $500
The packages differ in speed and features, and you can compare them on each page. Our services are performed in accordance with Islamic law, verified by qualified imams, with real-time updates and customer support. A portion of our profits is pledged to charity, including support for Gaza.

To start, book your Umrah. If you are thinking of a Hajj substitute instead, see our Hajj Badal pre-booking page.
Our view: a gift that finishes what they could not
Families usually come to us after a loss or a diagnosis, and the question under every message is the same: is there still something I can do for them?
The scholars’ answer is yes, and it is generous. Umrah on behalf of a person who has died is permitted and its reward reaches them. For a living person who cannot travel, a proxy is valid with their permission. Charity is also rewarded, and we encourage it. We do not see the two as competing. We see Umrah as the pilgrimage they could not make, and charity as the generosity that surrounds it.
What we care about is that the Umrah is done properly: by a proxy who has done his own, with the intention made for your loved one alone, and with proof you can keep. That is why we give photos, videos and a certificate, and why our work is verified by qualified imams. Pilgrimage for others is an amanah, a trust, and we treat it as one.
For you. For your loved ones. For their forgiveness.
anas
FAQ
Can Umrah be gifted to someone?
Yes. You can gift the reward of your own Umrah to a living person, and Islamweb.net says it reaches him. You can also have a proxy perform Umrah for someone who has died or who has a lasting inability to travel. A healthy person who is able to travel is not a case for a proxy.
Can I perform Umrah for a friend?
Yes, the doer does not need to be a relative. Any person who has performed Hajj and Umrah for himself can do it for another, according to Islamweb.net. If the friend is alive, they must be unable to travel and give permission.
Is it better to give charity or gift Umrah for a deceased parent?
Scholars recommend both for deceased parents, so you do not have to choose. Umrah on their behalf frees them of the obligation, and charity, especially sadaqah jariyah, keeps benefiting them. Many families do a proxy Umrah and add ongoing charity in the same name.
What is the difference between sadaqah and sadaqah jariyah?
Ordinary sadaqah benefits the recipient once, like a meal. Sadaqah jariyah is ongoing charity, such as a well, that keeps benefiting people and keeps rewarding the giver, even after death.
Can one Umrah be for two people?
No. Each Umrah belongs to one person only, so separate Umrahs are needed for separate people. A proxy can perform several, each with its own intention.
Sources
- Islamweb.net: Making 'Umrah on behalf of the living and the deceased
- Islamweb.net: Performing Umrah for others
- Islamweb.net: Performing 'Umrah on behalf of psychiatric patient
- Diyanet Affairs Presidency: Başkası Adına Umre Yapılabilir Mi?
- Iftaa’ Department, Jordan: Conditions for performing Hajj or Umrah on behalf of a sick person
- IslamQA.info: Mentioning the name of the person on whose behalf Umrah is done
- Al-Fatawa: Umrah and charity on behalf of a deceased person
- Al-Fatawa: Charity on behalf of one’s parents and performing Hajj and Umrah
- Arab News: Tawaf on Behalf of Others
- Assim Al Hakeem: Delegating someone to perform Umrah
- Al-Mawrid: Umrah vs Charity
- IslamQA (Hanafi): Miscellaneous questions on sadaqah jariyah
- Human Appeal: Sadaqah Jariyah for the Deceased
- Muslim Hands UK: What is Sadaqah Jariyah?
- Zakat.org: What Is Sadaqah Jariyah?
- Airport pickup for elderly travelers


